.png)
F is for Fair Leadership That People Trust
- Mar 24
- 3 min read
Welcome! This article is part of an A–Z series where I’m sharing reflections on the patterns I keep seeing in teams, leadership and workplace culture.
Not theory. Not tips. Just observations from real working life.
When people talk about leadership, we usually hear the same words: vision, strategy, resilience, and innovation. All important, of course. But in my experience, the leaders people genuinely trust often share something simpler - they’re fair. Not perfect. Not always popular. But consistently fair. That matters more than we sometimes realise.
Why Fairness Matters More Than We Think
If you ask most employees what they want from leadership, the answer isn’t complicated. They want to feel respected, listened to, and treated fairly. Yet the reality across many workplaces tells a different story. Research from Gallup found that only 37% of employees strongly agree they are treated with respect at work. That means nearly two-thirds of people don’t consistently feel respected in their workplace.
When fairness and respect are missing, trust erodes quickly. But when people believe their leader is fair, something powerful happens. People speak up more. They contribute ideas. They take ownership of their work. And they support each other.
Fair Doesn’t Mean Treating Everyone the Same
One of the biggest misconceptions about fairness is that it means treating everyone identically. Good leaders know that’s not true. Fairness is not about giving everyone the same thing. It’s about giving people what they need to succeed. A new starter might need more support. An experienced colleague might need more autonomy. Someone facing personal challenges might need flexibility.
Fair leaders don’t ask “Am I treating everyone the same?” They ask: “Am I applying the same principles to everyone?” That difference matters.
Fairness Is Also About Transparency
Another interesting insight from workplace research is that fairness isn’t just about outcomes - it’s about how decisions are made.
For example, research from Gartner found that only 32% of employees believe they are paid fairly. When employees believe pay decisions are unfair, they are 15% less likely to stay and significantly less engaged at work.
Often, the issue isn’t just the decision itself; it’s that people don’t understand how the decision was made. Fair leaders recognise this and take time to explain the “why”. Not everyone will agree with every decision, but people are far more likely to respect a decision when they understand the reasoning behind it.
The Leader’s Role Is Bigger Than We Think
Leadership behaviour has an enormous impact on how people experience fairness at work.
In fact, further research from Gallup shows that managers account for around 70% of the variation in employee engagement across teams. That’s a striking statistic, and it tells us something important... Culture isn’t created by posters, policies, or strategy decks. It's created by daily leadership behaviour, and fairness is one of the behaviours people notice most.
What Fair Leaders Actually Do
From what I’ve seen, fair leaders tend to do a few simple things consistently:
They make decisions based on clear principles, not personal preference.
They listen before deciding: Different perspectives lead to better judgment.
They explain their reasoning: Transparency builds understanding.
They hold everyone accountable, including themselves
Fairness only works when the standards apply to everyone.
The Ripple Effect of Fairness
When fairness becomes visible in leadership behaviour, it spreads. Teams become more collaborative. People feel safer speaking up. Trust grows. And over time, that trust doesn’t just sit with the leader - it extends to the whole organisation.
F is for Fair
So, when we talk about leadership development, maybe we should keep one simple reminder in mind: F is for Fair. Not because fairness makes leadership easy, but because it makes leadership trusted. And when trust is present, people and organisations do their best work.
If this resonated, it’s probably because you’re seeing it too.
Philippa x
Want to see more?
Follow me on LinkedIn →
Interested in finding out more?
I offer:
1:1 packages for business owners
Insights Discovery Sessions like Team Effectiveness and Leadership Effectiveness
Consultancy for businesses who want to create healthy workplace culture
